The struts are hard to rate for several reasons. They are stiffer and heavier than the OE struts. Over small bumps they do a better job of smoothing out the ride but, have a tendency to be a little rough on less refined roads. If you are a performance oriented commuter then these are great struts for you. However, if you're looking for a smooth ride, look elsewhere. Many companies advertise these struts as having a smoother ride overall, but I have yet to experience this. Note: The lower rating is not because the struts are bad--it has more to do with the advertising of the product and it's claims for a smoother, plusher ride. Despite this, I highly recommend these struts for the performance minded driver.