Jump to content


FCP Euro

Photo
* * * * * 3 votes

What Cylinder Head To Use For Best Performance With 2.3L Block?


This topic has been archived. This means that you cannot reply to this topic.
284 replies to this topic

#1 lookforjoe

lookforjoe

    Level 5 Member

  • Lifetime Supporter
  • 9,884 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 04:37 PM

OK, so this has come up in a bunch of different threads, and I'd like to see if we can concretely define which later heads are the best bang for the buck, and what mods are required in each case in one thread.

related threads: Why Build?
Ultimate Budget Build
What The Inside Of Your Head

Thoughts?

Some questions:

What year did they stop using the 2.3L?

Will 2.4 or 2.5 heads bolt on without issues to oil or water cooling passages?

Which cams/gears should be used to eliminate the VVT?

Do the crank / waterpump/ tensioner gears need to be changed for use of later cams (different belt/teeth configuration?)

VSXCsig3a_zps930bdcd1.jpg
1998 V70 XR M66 Quaife 14J PTE6262 BB Built '04 2.3l Block Wiseco Pistons 147mm H-Beams '03 Ported Head EnemY21Cams TurboTuner 710cc Inj, DW300, 3" DP back Dual Magnaflow 14834's Apr 2013 408WHP AWD (@7925rpm) 347WTq(@4400rpm)@18psi LGSpeed Header Custom Intake Manifold 30x12.5x3.5"Treadstone FMIC AP Racing Clutch KU SM Billet Flywheel Kaplhenke CoilOvers




#2 Hanks

Hanks

    Level 4 Member

  • Supporting Member
  • 3,507 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 05:10 PM

99-2000
99 2.3 T5  Single VVT
99 2.4 LPT Single VVT
00 2.4 R   Single VVT

2001-2004
2001-2004 2.3   T5   Single VVT
2001-2004 2.4   LPT  Single VVT
2005-2009 2.4   T5   Dual VVT
2003-2009 2.5   LPT  Dual VVT
2004-2009 2.5   S60R Dual VVT


NA VVT cars had VVT on the intake cam instead of the exhaust cam. It may be possible to use the non VVT exhaust cam. someone would have to verify the journals though..
Captain Bondo posted some info about him putting 960 cams into a s80 t6 motor, took a bit of machining but it worked.

when using the 99+ head/block+head you will need to use the accessory rack from the older style 93-98 850/x70 for the easiest swap. it is possible to use the newer style but the only problem would be with the power steering pump as the 99+ use an external PS fluid reservoir. Aaron was able to get the older style PS pump with some bracket modification for htownturbobricks car

IMO the best/cleanest setup (my setup) would be to use a 99+ steering rack along with keeping all the original accessories/accessory rack from the 99+ motor type. you will need to drill out the PS fluid reservoir/water reservoir bracket from the 99+ strut tower and tack, sand and repaint it onto the 850/x70 strut tower. you will also need to port match the 94-98 intake manifold to the 99+ head and use the older style thermostat bracket. using turbo tuner you will not have to put a cap and rotor onto the car as it is going to support coil on plug soon. This whole process completly gets rid of any hoses that are running between the rad/ic and the intake manifold. It is VERY clean look



thanks for opening this thread also :) lets keep it updated with any info we find out.

Edited by Hanks, 14 January 2010 - 06:02 PM.

-Kevin-

 

2004 V70R: 3 angle valve job, Phuzzy FMIC, IPD Neutral rear sway

White '96 850 T5M:Black '94 850 T5

Volvospeed Useful Threads For Repairs

VS Docs now live


#3 TurboedVolvo

TurboedVolvo

    Power Bottom

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 141 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 05:38 PM

OMG Finally this thread has been started!

Lets get some valuable input guys! This could be a sticky one day!

If we can pick up a later head that flows better than $3 g's worth of machining for under 800$

I would love to know more please everyone share your information!

1998 Volvo S70 T5 MODDED

12.6 @ 103 mph


#4 Hanks

Hanks

    Level 4 Member

  • Supporting Member
  • 3,507 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 05:50 PM

updated my post with a little more info.

-Kevin-

 

2004 V70R: 3 angle valve job, Phuzzy FMIC, IPD Neutral rear sway

White '96 850 T5M:Black '94 850 T5

Volvospeed Useful Threads For Repairs

VS Docs now live


#5 Ipd

Ipd

    Mr. IPD

  • Validating
  • PipPipPip
  • 1,562 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 06:20 PM

Here's what I can add.

Latest version R head gasket is MLS (multi layer steel) like a Cometic, this is the stock replacement. I got mine from Victor Reinz.
The cooling ports are different, they are staggered and will provide better cooling. Oil feed and crankcase drain ports are all compatible. If you use a non CVVT head with the MLS gasket you'll have to drill a few ports into the cooling passages in the head to get adequate cooling.
So this means a CVVT head will bolt onto a non CVVT block.

You cannot to my knowledge put a non CVVT cam in place of a cam that was CVVT.
The journals are significantly different, this is true for any potentional non CVVT cam be it earlier 870 style or later P2 style.
Obviously modification could be made to the head but it's not a drop in.

You can run a CVVT system on a car that didn't come equipped with it but you'll need a controller.
To control the CVVT solenoid you only have to vary the duty cycle - on time.
The frequency is fixed at 250 hz.
Acceptable duty cycle ranges from 20% to 95%.

The easiest way to control it is by setting up a 555 timer to trigger a TIP120 power transistor off a boost pressure sensor.
555 fixes the frequency at 250hz and the change in boost pressure (resistance change) will retard/advance the cam as load (boost) is increased.
Basic knowledge of electronics and intercooler is required to implement.

Setting up a proper advance/retard setting depends on mods but for a free flowing engine with aftermarket exhaust, downpipe, intake, intercooler, etc.. added overlap can be beneficial while stock engine will be better off with less overlap.

#6 TurboedVolvo

TurboedVolvo

    Power Bottom

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 141 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 06:30 PM

Here's what I can add.

Latest version R head gasket is MLS (multi layer steel) like a Cometic, this is the stock replacement. I got mine from Victor Reinz.
The cooling ports are different, they are staggered and will provide better cooling. Oil feed and crankcase drain ports are all compatible.
So this means a CVVT head will bolt onto a non CVVT block.

You cannot to my knowledge put a non CVVT cam in place of a cam that was CVVT.
The journals are significantly different, this is true for any potentional non CVVT cam be it earlier 870 style or later P2 style.
Obviously modification could be made to the head but it's not a drop in.

You can run a CVVT system on a car that didn't come equipped with it but you'll need a controller.
To control the CVVT solenoid you only have to vary the duty cycle - on time.
The frequency is fixed at 250 hz.
Acceptable duty cycle ranges from 20% to 95%.

The easiest way to control it is by setting up a 555 timer to trigger a TIP120 power transistor off a boost pressure sensor.
555 fixes the frequency at 250hz and the change in boost pressure (resistance change) will retard/advance the cam as load (boost) is increased.
Basic knowledge of electronics and intercooler is required to implement.

Setting up a proper advance/retard setting depends on mods but for a free flowing engine with aftermarket exhaust, downpipe, intake, intercooler, etc.. added overlap can be beneficial while stock engine will be better off with less overlap.


AWESOME INFORMATION LUCKY!

Any more information on what modifications would need to be made maybe HtownBrick will chime in

1998 Volvo S70 T5 MODDED

12.6 @ 103 mph


#7 Hanks

Hanks

    Level 4 Member

  • Supporting Member
  • 3,507 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 07:09 PM

aaron Juan did the work for htowntubrobrick.

updated with more info...

-Kevin-

 

2004 V70R: 3 angle valve job, Phuzzy FMIC, IPD Neutral rear sway

White '96 850 T5M:Black '94 850 T5

Volvospeed Useful Threads For Repairs

VS Docs now live


#8 ErikS

ErikS

    Not Pretentious

  • Lifetime Supporter
  • 5,439 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 07:50 PM

Juan did the work for htowntubrobrick.


He wishes :lol:

I picked a pretty circuitous route and arguably cheated slightly, but I'm going to get there
1995 854 T5M Click for Mods
2005 S60 2.5 T

2013 MB GLK 350


#9 Hanks

Hanks

    Level 4 Member

  • Supporting Member
  • 3,507 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 07:58 PM

He wishes :lol:

who did then? thats what htownturbobrick said.

ahhh nvm it was aaron! ajhehr

-Kevin-

 

2004 V70R: 3 angle valve job, Phuzzy FMIC, IPD Neutral rear sway

White '96 850 T5M:Black '94 850 T5

Volvospeed Useful Threads For Repairs

VS Docs now live


#10 AthruC

AthruC

    Level 1 Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 73 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 08:23 PM

This might not be of any help, but you did ask :D

This pertains to North American cars.


The 2.3L, as a block, was no longer used after 2005. The Gen. 1 T5's and R's generally lost .1L to the 'standard' motors, and in the P2, that was generally the case as well (except for the 2.5T which had some 'overlap'). As we all know, the 'earlier' T5's and R's were all -.1 except for the '00 VR which kept a 2.4L block.

P2's w/ a turbo were 2.4L's as the 'base' turbo car, which later went to the 2.5T. The 2001-2004 T5's were 2.3L, then in 2005, Volvo actually did some *good* trickle-down engineering and the T5 shared most components w/ the R's motor, but using a 2.4L block. The 05+ P2 T5's and P2 R's share crank, rods, head, cams, etc.

The P2 turbo cars all share the same valves.

Lucky, have you actually implemented a VVT circuit like the one you mentioned (like what you did w/ the 4C setup)? I am looking to do something just like what you describe with a 98 ECM and would love to be able to make the dual VVT (properly) functional.
1995 855 Turbo White/Beige (Lightly modded/DD/to be modded more) - 1995 854 T5R Cream Yellow/Charcoal (currently being refinished, to be for sale) - 1989 780 Turbo Black/Beige (currently being refinished, maybe to be for sale) - 2005 V70R Black/Atacama 6MT (To be donor for a White/Atacama VR replica) - Machined over TiGray 18" Pegs (for sale)

#11 HtownTurboBrick

HtownTurboBrick

    Level 5 Member

  • Supporting Member
  • 6,213 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 08:35 PM

Forwarding thread to Aaron
~Jon AKA: the ddrunkn trigr hapy pumckin~


- '98 S70 T5M w/ '00 R motor swap 266whp/340wtq on 16T - 98' S70 T5 Black: Former DD new project - 96' 850 GLT -

RIP Joe Ng 02/29/56-08/18/05...

#12 Hanks

Hanks

    Level 4 Member

  • Supporting Member
  • 3,507 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 08:53 PM

Here is a little more info in case some people want to read... just about what they changed

http://www.volvoclub...d_engines.shtml

-Kevin-

 

2004 V70R: 3 angle valve job, Phuzzy FMIC, IPD Neutral rear sway

White '96 850 T5M:Black '94 850 T5

Volvospeed Useful Threads For Repairs

VS Docs now live


#13 Johann

Johann

    "THE MAN"

  • OH Moderator
  • 5,156 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 09:06 PM

2001-2004 2.3 T5 Single VVT
2001-2004 2.4 LPT Single VVT
2005-2009 2.4 T5 Single VVT
2003-2009 2.5 LPT Dual VVT
2004-2009 2.5 S60R Dual VVT




sig3.jpg


#14 Hanks

Hanks

    Level 4 Member

  • Supporting Member
  • 3,507 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 09:19 PM

thanks, edited.

so it looks like the 2003 lpt would be a great motor to get!

-Kevin-

 

2004 V70R: 3 angle valve job, Phuzzy FMIC, IPD Neutral rear sway

White '96 850 T5M:Black '94 850 T5

Volvospeed Useful Threads For Repairs

VS Docs now live


#15 Ipd

Ipd

    Mr. IPD

  • Validating
  • PipPipPip
  • 1,562 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 09:20 PM

Lucky, have you actually implemented a VVT circuit like the one you mentioned (like what you did w/ the 4C setup)? I am looking to do something just like what you describe with a 98 ECM and would love to be able to make the dual VVT (properly) functional.

Yes but i just used a piggy back system with an additional tuning map for the vvt. So didn't use the 555/tip120/boost sensor method.

#16 ajhehr

ajhehr

    Level 2 Member

  • Lifetime Supporter
  • 886 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 09:27 PM

I know at least the 2000 v70r uses 7mm valve stems instead of the smaller 6mm on the early.
both are sodium filled to my knowledge.

the later solid lifter head flows more stock then my hydraulic lifter head with full gasket match and port and polish. I always hesitate to say flow numbers in CFM because there is so much variance in between flow benches.

on the same flow bench though our solid lifter heads at least in static flow is comparable to your honda k20a2 head, where our head lacks vs the honda is in the cam profiles.

#17 Johann

Johann

    "THE MAN"

  • OH Moderator
  • 5,156 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 10:01 PM

I know at least the 2000 v70r uses 7mm valve stems instead of the smaller 6mm on the early.


AFAIK all engine's up to the solid lifter type use 7 mm stems. With the lifter type change the valve stem size changed.

sig3.jpg


#18 Hanks

Hanks

    Level 4 Member

  • Supporting Member
  • 3,507 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 10:13 PM

Johann,

would you happen to have any pictures with the cam cover taken off? it would be interesting to see if a NA VVT head exhaust cam(non vvt cam) has the correct journals to put in place of the VVT turbo exhaust cam.

-Kevin-

 

2004 V70R: 3 angle valve job, Phuzzy FMIC, IPD Neutral rear sway

White '96 850 T5M:Black '94 850 T5

Volvospeed Useful Threads For Repairs

VS Docs now live


#19 AthruC

AthruC

    Level 1 Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 73 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 10:26 PM

Yes but i just used a piggy back system with an additional tuning map for the vvt. So didn't use the 555/tip120/boost sensor method.


I may not be as familiar with the VVT on these heads (including dual VVT), but I was under the impression that the VVT was only load dependent once past a certain rpm (generally, where the horsepower and torque curves intersect, the lower range giving the equivalent of running 'NA cam' timing and the higher range 'turbo cam' timing?

Once you do get to dual variable, that does mess things up a hair, so do you focus on just one variable (load), or do you base it on engine speed? Can you (easily) 'tune' the timing based on both?
1995 855 Turbo White/Beige (Lightly modded/DD/to be modded more) - 1995 854 T5R Cream Yellow/Charcoal (currently being refinished, to be for sale) - 1989 780 Turbo Black/Beige (currently being refinished, maybe to be for sale) - 2005 V70R Black/Atacama 6MT (To be donor for a White/Atacama VR replica) - Machined over TiGray 18" Pegs (for sale)

#20 Captain Bondo

Captain Bondo

    Level 2 Member

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 639 posts

Posted 11 January 2010 - 11:23 PM

As was said, the switch to 6mm stems came on later motors with solid lifters.

Solid lifter cams have a 2mm larger base circle, but solid lifters are a different height. It would be cool to know if they are 2mm shorter and therefore the length of the 6mm and 7mm valves is the same and it therefore would all interchange.
Also the post seemed to suggest that 7mm stems was some sort of upgrade. That's also backwards. You want 6mm stems if you can.

Cam timing needs to be load and RPM dependent. Using only one or the other, I'd use RPM before I used load, but really you need to use both for it to work well.




IPD Volvo Parts


Copyright 2013 Volvospeed