What do you think?
My thoughts:
In no other major ball or puck based sport does a tied score lead to a finals scenario where players get a free shot at the goal. We don't put the football on the opposing team's 20 yard line and give each team 5 shots at getting a field goal or touchdown in the Superbowl. We don't line each team's five best foul shooters up in basketball and give them each a shot at making a basket for the final game of the NBA finals. In baseball we don't line up the home run hitters and see how many home runs they can hit against a pitcher in the World Series. We don't put the five best puck handlers on the line and do a shoot out - at least not in NHL play for the Stanley cup though they do in regular play and they do have shootouts in International including the Olympics and lower league play in the US and Canada).
It's less concerning to see a team win a regular season game through a shoot out in hockey. But to watch an underdog that has played magnificently lose in the Stanley Cup finals because the other team had a better line of shooters, something doesn't quit sit right. And that's why they don't do it in hockey.
At least that is what Blatter is saying in the case of football. He doesn't think it's right.
So, should they go into a second and third overtime for football (soccer)? It's hard to say. There is something gut wrenching and yet fascinating to watch exhausted goalies and kickers stand man to man and try to be the hero rather than the goat. As a goalie in youth football, I always hated having to take on a penalty kick, especially when it was one of my own teammates who caused the penalty. I wound up being the goat if I didn't block the goal, not the teammate who made the stupid mistake.
But in the case of football, how long would the game go if we let it run into multiple overtimes rather than going to the shootout after an initial overtime? Does the shootout offer a dramatic ending rather than an exhausted and deflating finish? Would eliminating the shootout change the strategic play of the game where some teams ultimately play out the clock in an effort to get to the shootout phase in hopes of a better result?
Me, I love the shootout. It's a dramatic finish to the game. And it truly pits a skilled goalie against great kickers. I can't say I've ever felt regret that a team like Italy won over France in the World Cup or that Brazil beat Italy. Or that the USA defeated China in the 1999 Women's FIFA World Cup or Japan beat the USA in 2011.
You wouldn't have moments like these:

Or this:

So how would you change it - or should FIFA just tell Blatter to leave well enough alone?





Find content
Male





