A case of Beaujolais ?! Nice! The jerrsey would be cool too but the wine would do!
Patrick: rain gear for cycling. Easily found on Amazon, Nashbar or even better: your local bike shop.
Kevin: a dildo. Seriously, that joke's not dead yet.
Timo: a gift card to GNC
Jon: weed, lots of it. Dude needs to chill.
Erik: I gave him a book on traveling last year, I think. I dunno, dude has it all. Cool job, smart and attractive wife, healthy kid, fast cars, etc....
AJ: hiking stuff, outdoor gear
Adam: pizza
Greg: detailing supplies.
Mike: BMW swag (go fast parts, not the pretty dealer overpriced junk)
Tommy: bike stuff, a gift card to his local liquor store
Mike: Tack strips. I hear he likes them a lot.
You're welcome.